Guide · Gold Weights & Calculations

Making Charges: Percentage vs Per Gram — Which Is Cheaper?

Making Charges: Percentage vs Per Gram — Which Is Cheaper?

Neither is always cheaper. A percentage making charge rises and falls with the gold rate; a per-gram charge is a fixed amount for each gram, whatever gold does. To compare them, convert the percentage into dirhams per gram: multiply the gold rate by the percentage. If the result is lower than the per-gram quote, the percentage is cheaper today.

So 8% on 22K at AED 360 a gram is AED 28.80 a gram. Against a flat AED 25 a gram, the flat charge wins by AED 3.80 on every gram.

The two ways shops quote making

Per gramPercentage
How it's written"AED 20 per gram""8% making"
Calculated onNet gold weightGold value (weight × rate)
When gold risesStays the same per gramRises with it
Easy to compare across shops?Yes, if the weight is the sameOnly once converted
Common inDubai Gold Souk, plain designsIndian jewellers, branded showrooms

Some Dubai shops quote a flat amount for the whole piece, especially for small or highly crafted items. Treat that the same way: divide by the net weight to get a per-gram figure.

The break-even formula

Break-even per-gram charge = gold rate per gram × percentage.

If the per-gram charge you're offered is below that number, it's the better deal. If it's above, the percentage is cheaper. Here's how it plays out at three different gold rates, all illustrative.

22K rate (AED/g)5% equals8% equals12% equals
300AED 15.00/gAED 24.00/gAED 36.00/g
360AED 18.00/gAED 28.80/gAED 43.20/g
420AED 21.00/gAED 33.60/gAED 50.40/g

Notice the pattern. The higher gold goes, the more a percentage charge costs in dirhams, even though nothing about the craftsmanship changed. When gold is expensive, a fixed per-gram charge tends to look better.

Today's live rates, which you'll need for your own break-even sum, are below.

Three purchases, worked both ways

A 24 g plain 22K chain

Shop A: AED 25 per gram. Shop B: 8%. Gold rate AED 360.

  • Shop A making: 24 × 25 = AED 600
  • Shop B making: 24 × 360 × 8% = AED 691.20
  • Difference: AED 91.20 before VAT, in Shop A's favour

A 6 g handcrafted 22K pendant

Shop A: AED 40 per gram. Shop B: 12%.

  • Shop A making: 6 × 40 = AED 240
  • Shop B making: 6 × 360 × 12% = AED 259.20
  • Difference: AED 19.20, again in Shop A's favour, but small

An 18K diamond ring, 4 g of gold

18K at an illustrative AED 270 a gram. Shop A: AED 60 per gram. Shop B: 18%.

  • Shop A making: 4 × 60 = AED 240
  • Shop B making: 4 × 270 × 18% = AED 194.40
  • Difference: AED 45.60, this time in Shop B's favour

The lesson: on lower-karat gold, a percentage applies to a lower rate, so a high percentage can still be cheaper than a high flat charge. Always convert before deciding.

VAT at 5% then applies to the gold plus making, so any saving on making is slightly larger once VAT is added.

Watch for these quoting tricks

  • Percentage on gross weight. On a stone-set piece, 10% of a value calculated on gross weight is more than 10% of net. Ask which weight the percentage uses.
  • Percentage on the 24K rate. The percentage should be on the rate for the karat you're buying, not on 24K.
  • "Low making" with a high rate. A shop advertising tiny making charges may be using a gold rate above the published daily rate. Check both.
  • Minimum charges. Small pieces often have a minimum making amount that overrides the per-gram figure.

When the timing of the quote matters

For a piece you buy off the shelf, the rate and the making are fixed at billing, and the comparison above is all you need. Custom orders are different. If you order a set today and collect it in two weeks, ask which day's gold rate will apply and whether the making is fixed in dirhams or tied to the rate.

A per-gram charge agreed at order stays the same even if gold jumps before delivery. A percentage charge rises with the rate on billing day. On a 60 g bridal order with 10% making, a rise of AED 15 a gram in the 22K rate adds AED 90 to the making alone, on top of the higher gold value. Getting the making written down as a fixed per-gram figure removes one source of surprise.

Making is a cost you don't get back

When you later sell or exchange jewellery, buyers pay for the gold content, not the making. So every dirham of making is the price of the design and craft. That's not a reason to avoid it, only a reason to make sure it's spent on pieces you'll wear. For gold bought mainly as savings, low-making designs or bars make more sense.

Which should you ask for?

In the Gold Souk, you can often choose. A sensible approach:

  1. Ask for making as a per-gram figure on net weight.
  2. Convert any percentage quote into per-gram using today's rate.
  3. Compare that number across two or three shops for similar designs.
  4. Negotiate on making, not the gold rate, which is set daily.

For machine-made chains and plain bangles, making should be low. For handcrafted, antique, Polki or Kundan work, it's higher, and that's fair. What isn't fair is paying a handcrafted rate on a machine-made piece. Our guide to making charges in Dubai covers what drives the price up or down, and the bargaining guide covers how to bring it down.

How Indian "wastage" fits in

Some Indian jewellers, especially in the South, add a "wastage" or "value addition" percentage on top of, or instead of, making. Functionally, it's another percentage on gold value and should be converted the same way. Our explainer on wastage charges covers how to compare it with a Dubai per-gram quote.

Making charge decision in one minute

  • Percentage × today's rate for that karat = per-gram equivalent.
  • Lower per-gram equivalent wins.
  • Confirm the charge is on net weight.
  • Add 5% VAT on gold plus making for the final figure.
  • Run the numbers through the calculator, and see our jewellery price guide and per-gram pillar for the full bill.

Written by Sagar Yadav and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

Are making charges negotiable in Dubai?
Yes, at most Gold Souk shops making charges are negotiable, while the gold rate itself follows the published daily rate. You will usually have more room on plain, machine-made designs than on complex handcrafted pieces. Comparing quotes from two or three shops helps.
Why do some shops prefer percentage making charges?
A percentage scales automatically with the gold price and the piece's value, which is simple for the shop to apply across many designs. It also means the shop earns more in dirhams when gold is expensive. For you, it is only better when it converts to a lower per-gram amount.
Is VAT charged on making charges in the UAE?
Yes. The 5% UAE VAT applies to the whole jewellery invoice, including both the gold value and the making charge. Eligible overseas tourists can reclaim part of it through the airport refund scheme at participating stores.

More in Gold Weights & Calculations